Everyone knows that renovations can be just as stressful as they are exciting. Undertaking any home improvement project comes with risks, and one of the biggest concerns for homeowners is poor workmanship. Shoddy construction or faulty installations can lead to significant problems and costly repairs.
Unfortunately, many homeowners assume that their insurance coverage will protect them from these risks, but it's important to understand what’s covered and what’s not. Ensuring your home is well-protected begins with understanding the limitations of standard insurance and exploring your additional coverage options. Let’s take a closer look before you get started on your next project.
Home Insurance Policies and Poor Workmanship
When you invest in a home improvement project, the last thing you expect is for things to go wrong — like a dodgy contractor leaving your new kitchen or bathroom in shambles. Unfortunately, while home insurance won’t cover the cost of redoing any poor workmanship, it can still protect you from other costs that arise as a result. For example, if faulty wiring leads to a fire or a burst pipe floods your home, your insurance may help cover the damage, but not the faulty work itself.
Imagine this scenario: You hire a contractor to install new plumbing, but they do a poor job, and a pipe bursts, damaging your kitchen floors and walls. In this case, while your insurance won’t cover redoing the shoddy plumbing work, your buildings insurance can help with structural damage, while your contents insurance will cover the damaged appliances. Before you begin any renovations, it’s important to understand how different parts of your policy can step in when things go wrong.
Here are the different ways your insurance can help:
Contents insurance: Covers damaged belongings or appliances.
Buildings insurance: Covers structural damage to your home’s walls, floors, or built-in fittings.
Alternative accommodation cover: Helps pay for emergency accommodation if your home is unliveable during repairs.
Legal expenses cover: If you need to take your contractor to court, your insurance may cover your legal fees.
Home emergency cover: This type of cover means you can get a professional out to help ASAP in the event of a home emergency like a burst pipe, dodgy boiler, or something else that needs immediate attention.
Of course, every home insurance policy is different, so be sure to check with your insurer about what types of cover you have and the limits involved. Don’t get caught short!
Are you about to start a home renovation project? Before you do anything else, read our blog post, Do I Need Building Insurance When Renovating? This will answer all the most important questions and help you get the right type of cover before starting.
Insurance Your Contractor Should Have
Before any work begins, it’s essential to confirm that your contractor has the right insurance to protect you if things go wrong. In the UK, contractors should have:
Public Liability Insurance: This is a must. It covers any damage to your property or injuries that occur during the project. For instance, if a contractor accidentally damages your flooring, this insurance will cover the repair costs.
Contractor’s Insurance: This protects against risks during the construction process, such as materials being damaged or stolen before installation. It can also cover damage caused during the project itself.
Professional Indemnity Insurance: If a contractor offers advice or designs as part of the job and things go wrong because of poor advice, this insurance will cover the cost of correcting those mistakes.
Employer’s Liability Insurance: If the contractor employs workers, this is legally required in the UK. It covers the costs if an employee is injured on the job.
Always ask for proof of insurance before hiring a contractor and verify the coverage with their provider. Having this in place ensures you aren’t left to deal with the financial fallout if something goes wrong.
Poor Workmanship: Common Scenarios
Poor workmanship can show up in various ways, and even minor mistakes can lead to bigger issues later on. Faulty plumbing is one common example, where improperly installed pipes can cause leaks or bursts, leading to water damage. Electrical mistakes are another concern, as these can result in power failures or even create safety hazards like fires. Then, there are roofing issues, where poor installation can lead to persistent leaks and eventual structural damage. Even things like badly laid flooring or misaligned windows can cause uneven surfaces, drafts, and unnecessary wear and tear.
It’s not just about how things look — poor workmanship often means dealing with higher repair costs, further damage to your home and contents, or ongoing issues down the line.
What’s the moral of the story here? Be sure you have the right kind of coverage when having home improvements done. And to save yourself months of potential legal proceedings, be sure your contractors all have current and adequate insurance of their own!
Legal Framework for Poor Workmanship
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires that services provided by contractors must be completed with reasonable care and skill. If a contractor’s work is substandard, you can request a remedy under the Act, which may involve redoing the job or a price reduction.
You can also seek help through trading standards or legal advice if disputes arise. For more complex cases, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is often recommended before going to court. It's essential to know your rights when facing poor workmanship.
The Claims Process for Poor Workmanship
Filing a poor workmanship insurance claim can be challenging, as home insurance usually won’t cover the faulty work itself, but might cover resulting property damage. If you have legal expense cover, you can file a claim for the legal fees needed to pursue action against the contractor. Start by gathering all relevant documents, such as contracts and receipts, and evidence, like photos of the damage. Contact your insurance company to initiate the claim, explaining the issue and providing documentation.
Be aware that most policies have limits, and any negligence on the homeowner’s part (e.g., not reporting problems early) may affect the outcome. Keeping good records and staying in touch with your insurer will help you avoid the common pitfalls.
Selecting a Contractor
We’ve already mentioned it above, but it’s worth stating again: To avoid poor workmanship issues, always choose contractors with valid contractor insurance. This ensures that any damage caused during the job will be covered by the person or firm who completed the work. How do you do this, exactly? Ask for proof of insurance and verify it with the provider. When searching for reliable contractors, look for reviews, ask for references, and check that they’re members of relevant professional associations.
Doing so can save you from headaches and potential insurance claims later on. Some of the key associations to look at include:
Federation of Master Builders (FMB): Ensures contractors adhere to quality building standards.
National Federation of Builders (NFB): Represents construction companies committed to high standards.
Gas Safe Register (GASSAFE): Required for contractors working with gas appliances.
NICEIC, ECA, and NAPIT: These regulate electricians and ensure they meet UK safety standards.
TrustMark: A government-endorsed quality scheme for tradespeople.
These associations provide greater reliability and accountability for contractors.
Don’t Let Poor Workmanship Ruin Your Home
Poor workmanship can lead to really costly repairs and disputes, which is why it’s so important to know your insurance policy’s limits. While home insurance may cover property damage, it rarely covers the faulty work itself. Proactive steps like choosing insured contractors and having legal expense cover can protect you from financial loss.
And, as we always say: Don’t get caught out being underinsured (like so many people do)!
For comprehensive coverage and peace of mind, consider a rebuild cost assessment with RebuildCostASSESSMENT.com to ensure your home is properly insured.
Other Helpful Resources
Important disclaimer: The information provided here is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional advice. While we strive to ensure all information is accurate and up-to-date, the content may not reflect the most current legal or regulatory developments, standards, or practices. No representations or warranties are made (express or implied) about the accuracy of the information provided, and reliance on this information is strictly at your own risk.
We do not offer financial advice and nothing within this content should be construed as such. We recommend consulting with a qualified professional who can provide tailored advice based on your individual circumstances before making any decisions related to insurance.
Please note that we are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and as such, are not qualified to provide specific financial or insurance advice. Please see our footer for further information about us, including our website terms of use, privacy policy and more.